OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL
Department of Homeland Security
fraudulent documents –– does not comply with the overall intent of the
requirement in the I-9 Guide to take timely and affirmative enforcement action.
The I-9 Guide, in these circumstances, includes steps ICE officials follow to
notify employers of suspected unauthorized workers, but the I-9 Guide does
not include guidance on how or under what circumstances ICE officials should
administratively arrest suspected UAWs. ICE’s I-9 inspection guidance has not
been updated in the past 12 years. Without additional guidance regarding the
protocols and processes to perform administrative arrests of UAWs identified
during I-9 inspections and verify the identity of individuals using fraudulent
documentation, ICE officials cannot ensure that these individuals do not have
criminal records. Additionally, ICE officials cannot ensure UAWs will not
remain free to seek employment elsewhere.
ICE’s Outreach Program Did Not Achieve Measurable Progress
ICE created the IMAGE program to reduce vulnerabilities related to
employment of illegal aliens by offering employers education and training to
improve their awareness of and compliance with Federal laws.
10
Employers
who participate in the IMAGE program must undergo I-9 inspection and agree
to specific hiring practices and terms to receive IMAGE program certification
and benefits, such as potential fine mitigation; a 2-year I-9 inspection reprieve;
and WSE information and training before, during, and after I-9 inspections.
The goal of IMAGE is to reduce illegal employment, eliminate unfair labor
advantages, and ultimately create a culture of compliance.
However, the IMAGE program is not impactful or cost effective. Since 2006,
ICE officials have reported conducting more than 20,000 IMAGE presentations
to more than 131,000 employers, by participating at trade shows, conferences,
and industry events, as well as conducting numerous live and virtual trainings.
We estimated that ICE has spent an average of $1.8 million per year during
FYs 2016 through 2018 to administer the IMAGE program. However, only 433
employers out of approximately 30 million businesses
11
in the United States
have joined the IMAGE program to date.
According to ICE officials, low participation in the IMAGE program is because
employers do not recognize the benefits of joining IMAGE. Such benefits
include reductions of fines assessed as a result of inspections or deferral of
subsequent I-9 inspections for 2 years. ICE officials said employers are
skeptical about voluntarily opening their books for I-9 inspection if the
potential to be fined remains. In January 2019, ICE officials issued a
10
The program is briefly mentioned in the FYs 2016-2020 ICE Strategic Plan, the FYs 2016-
2020 HSI Strategy, the FY 2018 WSE Strategy, and the Guide to WSE Investigations.
11
U.S. Small Business Administration, Office of Advocacy, 2018 Small Business Profiles.
www.oig.dhs.gov 11 OIG-21-15