History of Dutchess County
Bench and Bar
Albert M. Rosenblatt
1 07/07/2015
The Historical Society of the New York Courts
Dutchess County Legal History
Albert M. Rosenblatt
1
I. County Origins 2
a. General Narrative 2
b. Legal Beginnings 3
c. Timeline 5
II. County Courthouses; from the First to the Present (Fifth) 7
III. The Bench and the Bar 10
a. Judges 10
b. Attorneys and District Attorneys 19
c. Dutchess County Bar Association 26
d. Women 31
e. African Americans 34
f. Current Judiciary (2015) 35
IV. Cases and Trials of Note 37
V. County Resources 40
a. Bibliography 40
b. County Legal Records and their locations 42
c. County History Contacts 43
i. County, City, Town, and Village Historians 43
ii. Locations of Records 49
iii. County Clerk Records Index 49
Acknowledgements
With thanks to the Dutchess County Judiciary, the Dutchess County Bar Association, its Executive
Director Janna DeVito Whearty and former Executive Director Marie Meehan Komisar, Dutchess
County Clerk Brad Kendall and his assistant, Maria Bell; the Dutchess County Historical Society, the
Historical Society of the New York Courts and its Executive Director Marilyn Marcus, and special thanks
to Assistant Director Michael Benowitz for his help in formatting and readying it for publication.
1
Judge Rosenblatt, a graduate of the University of Pennsylvania and Harvard Law School, is retired from the New York
Court of Appeals. For his judicial biography, see p. 12.
2 07/07/2015
I. County Origins
a. General Narrative
In 1609, while under commission from the Dutch and looking for an efficient trade route to the Far
East, Henry Hudson discovered the river that bears his name. Captaining the ship Halve Maen, he
sailed north, and in September of that year passed what would later be known as Dutchess County, on
his east.
1
Dr. William T. (Chip) Reynolds Director, New Netherland Museum and Captain, Replica Ship Half Moon
emailed this writer that according to his calculations
“Henry Hudson and the half moon passed what would
become Poughkeepsie on September 15, 1609 when
northbound and September 28 when southbound. Their
anchorage on September 28 was close to the site of
Poughkeepsie.”
At the time, and for untold centuries before that, Native
American tribes inhabited both sides of the river.
2
The region that would become Dutchess County was
initially part of New Netherland, which the Dutch –
under a patent that the
Dutch States General issued to the Dutch West India Company – settled in
the 1620s, mostly around the areas that would later form New York City
and Albany.
In 1664, New Netherland, including the Hudson River Valley territory, fell
to a British naval force, and England would command the east coast of
America from Nova Scotia to Carolinas. The Dutch briefly recaptured the
territory in 1673, but in 1674, the English regained the Colony under the
Treaty of Westminster.
3
Thus, for a century after the Dutch, and until the Declaration of
Independence in 1776, we were a British Colony. The region to become
Dutchess County was part of a proprietary government of James, Duke of
York, until 1685 when the Duke became King James II of England, and New
York became a royal province, and so remained until the Revolution.
1
Smith, Philip H. General History of Dutchess County (Pawling, NY: 1877) at 23.
2
Any treatment of the preexisting native American life in the region falls outside the scope of this work, but there are
writings on the subject, e.g. Ruttenber, E.M. History of the Tribes of Hudson’s River (J. Munsell: 1872); Dunn, Shirley W. The
River Indians – Mohicans Making History (Purple Mountain Press: 2009); Gehring, Charles T. and Starna, William A., "Dutch
and Indians in the Hudson Valley: The Early Period" The Hudson Valley Regional Review 9.2 (Sept. 1992): 1-25; Funk, Robert.
Recent Contributions to Hudson Valley Prehistory (Albany: University of the State of New York, 1976)
3
For the Dutch New Netherland period see generally Jacobs, Jaap. New Netherland, A Dutch Colony in Seventeenth Century
America (New York: Cornell University Press, 2005); Benjamin, Vernon. The History of the Hudson River Valley: From
Wilderness to the Civil War (New York: Overlook Press, 2014); Jacobs, Jaap and Roper, L.H. The World of the Seventeenth-
Century Hudson Valley (New York: SUNY Press, 2014); Rosenblatt, A. and Rosenblatt, J. Opening Statements: Law,
Jurisprudence, and the Culture of Dutch New York (New York: SUNY Press, 2014)
The Halve Maen, circa 1609. By Tom Austin
King James II, 1683. By Sir
Godfrey Kneller
3 07/07/2015
b. Legal Beginnings
The history of Dutchess County, as a political entity, begins in 1683, when the English divided New York
colony into 12 counties, including Dutchess, which at the time, “had not a single European/non Native
American pioneer.”
1
In addition to “The Dutchess’s County,” the other eleven counties born as siblings in 1683 were:
Albany, Cornwall, Dukes, Kings, New York, Orange, Queens,
Richmond, Suffolk, Ulster, and Westchester.
2
Farewell Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard
These counties all remain in New York except for Cornwall and
Dukes, which Massachusetts gained in 1691. Dukes County “to
conteyne the Islands of Nantucket, Martins [now Martha’s]
Vinyard, Elizabeth Island and no mans Land” (an island near
Martha’s Vineyard).
3
Dutchess was named for Mary of Modena, Duchess of York,
second wife of James, Duke of York.
4
Within the dozen years from 1685 to 1697, the Crown granted 13
patents including the Rombout, Beekman, Oblong, Philipse, and
Nine Partners–names well known in Dutchess County today, and
so the settlements soon begun.
5
The Philipse patent includes
much of Putnam County, which was set off from Dutchess County
in 1812.
6
Settlement under Robert Livingston began at about that time.
7
The Livingston family produced
prominent members of the bench, bar, and government, including Chancellor Robert Livingston (1746-
1813), one of the authors of New York’s first Constitution in 1777.
1
McCracken, Henry N. Old Dutchess Forever! New York (Hastings House, 1926) at 16; Smith, James H. History of Dutchess
County (New York: D. Mason & Co., 1882) at 55; Tatum, III, William P. “The Birth of a County: Establishing a Government in
Dutchess, 1713- 1721” in Dutchess County Historical Society 2013 Yearbook, 5-16.
2
Laws of the Colony of New York Vol 1, L. 1683, Ch. 4.
3
Id.
4
This brings us to a fundamental dilemma. How can a county be named Dutchess, after a Duchess? How did the letter “T”
become so prominent a part of the county’s identity? Was it a tribute to the Dutch? An act of sheer negligence or
misspelling? Or any one of a dozen other theories? This dispute has raged for generations and, as we have said in another
context, the matter lies beyond the scope of this writing. For those interested in pursuing it, there is ample scholarship,
although we caution that the dispute will likely go on forever, at least we hope so. (e.g. Mahan, Harold E. Benson J. Lossing
and Historical Writing in the United States (Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1996) at 22, n2; “Lossing and Dutchess County”
Saturday Review of Books and Art, New York Times, Sept. 30, 1899, p. BR653; “The “T” in Dutchess”, in McCracken, supra, at
24-27 (Invoking, no less, Dr. Samuel Johnson and William Cullen Bryant.) These are deep waters indeed.
5
See generally Smith, supra at 47 et seq.
6
See Smith, supra at 43.
7
Smith, supra at 46.
Robert Livingston. Attributed to Gilbert
Stuart.
4 07/07/2015
Judge Hendrick Beekman served as Justice of the Peace for Ulster
County (of which Dutchess had been a part) in 1684 and
represented Ulster in the first elected Assembly under the King in
1691. In that same year, the colonial Assembly created the
Supreme Court of Judicature, granting it jurisdiction akin to
England’s King’s Bench, Common Pleas, and Exchequer.
On October 23, 1713, Royal Governor Robert Hunter signed a bill
allowing Dutchess County to form its own government and to
“Elect a Supervisor, a Treasurer, assessors and Collectors”
8
Dutchess was thus represented as a separate county in the
General Assembly of the Province.
9
After all, according to a 1714
census Dutchess had grown to inhabit about 445 people and
warranted its own government. By 1723, Dutchess’s population
was 1,083; by 1737, it was 3,418; by 1746, it was 8,806; and by
1771, it had grown to 22,404.
10
Leonard Lewis (1667-1730) was
the first Dutchess County judge.
8
Laws of the Colony of New York, L. 1713, Ch. 271.
9
Smith, supra at 48.
10
See Smith at 101.
Robert Hunter, circa 1720.
Attributed to Sir Godfrey Kneller
5 07/07/2015
c. Timeline
1609 Sept. 17 – Henry Hudson sails past Poughkeepsie
1664 Under Dutch rule since the 1620s, New Netherland, a colony that included what would be
known as Dutchess County (then unsettled by non-Native Americans) came under British rule,
under the Duke of York. New Netherland becomes New York.
1673 The Dutch recapture the colony including what later became known as Dutchess County.
1674 The Dutch and English enter into the Treaty of Westminster under which the British secure the
colony and rule for almost a century – until the American Revolution.
1683 Dutchess (The Dutchess’s County) becomes one of 12 colonies within New York. (L. 1683, Ch. 4)
Dutchess County, with virtually no European settlers, is administered by Ulster County.
1691 By “An Act to Divide the Province and Dependence into Shires and Counties” authorities set the
County’s boundaries. (L. 1691, Ch. 17)
1713 Dutchess forms its own government, with power to “Elect a Supervisor, a Treasurer, assessors
and Collectors” (L. 1713, Ch. 271)
1715 An “Act for building a County-House and Prison” (L. 1715, Ch. 297)
1777 In New York’s first Constitution, the drafters created an Assembly to consist of at least seventy
members to be chosen annually in the several counties, in proportions in which Dutchess was
to have seven, New York: nine, Albany: ten, Westchester: six, Ulster: six, Suffolk: five, Queens:
four, Kings: two, Richmond: two, Tryon (Montgomery): six, Charlotte (Washington): four,
Cumberland (now in Vermont): three, and Gloucester (now in Vermont): two.
1781 Proclamation from Governor George Clinton requiring the Assembly and Senate to convene at
Poughkeepsie to select delegates to the Continental Congress. After the British burned
Kingston in 1777, Poughkeepsie served as New York’s state capitol. The State Senate met in
Poughkeepsie, among other locations, in 1780, 1781, 1782, and 1788.
1788 At the Poughkeepsie courthouse, New York ratifies the Unites States Constitution.
1796 The New York State Legislature divides the state into seven districts with an assistant attorney
general to serve in each. Dutchess was grouped with Orange and Ulster (L. 1796, Ch. 8)
1801 The Legislature creates “district attorneys” with Dutchess grouped in a district with Rockland,
Orange, Ulster, and Delaware Counties (L. 1801, Ch. 146)
1812 Putnam County is split off from Dutchess.
1870 The Legislature establishes four departments in the State; Dutchess County is in the second (L.
1870, Ch. 408)
1906 By Constitutional Amendment taking effect January 1, 1906, the Legislature creates the 9th
judicial district, which includes Dutchess County
1944 The 1944 presidential election is the only one in which both major-party presidential candidates
came from the same county – Dutchess County. Democrat Franklin D. Roosevelt (Hyde Park)
defeated Republican Thomas E. Dewey (Pawling).
6 07/07/2015
1967 Voters approve the Dutchess County Charter, which divides the government into two branches:
legislative and executive, and sets forth the details of administration of the Dutchess County
government.
7 07/07/2015
II. County Courthouses
The present courthouse on Market Street in Poughkeepsie is the County’s fifth.
Author’s Note: The dates of the first three courthouses are inexact and sometimes conflicting. I have relied on
secondary sources, and would caution scholars to consult primary sources where possible.
The First Courthouse
Having begun its own government in 1713, as separate from Ulster County, the officials would have
conducted legal business in a building that served as a courthouse in Poughkeepsie.
On July 21, 1715, authorities had decreed the construction of a court house by 1717.
1
Henry Van de
(sometimes van den) Bogart (sometimes Bogert) and Barendt Van Kleeck conveyed the deed to the
land.
2
A well-known right of reverter has it that the property will revert back to the Van de Bogert
family if the property is not used, as least in part, as a jail, according to Platt’s History of Poughkeepsie
at page 20. Attorney Arthur L. Gellert has the ancient jailhouse key in his memorabilia collection.
There seems to have been delays, and it is difficult to discern exactly when the court house was built−
likely before 1720, and it is also difficult to pinpoint how long it lasted. According to former County
Historian Joyce Ghee,
3
we do know that on December 17, 1743 authorities passed an act to “enlarge
and Repair the old one,” which the County did in 1745.
4
Ms. Ghee writes that when the 1714 Van Den
Bogert deed of gift was filed in 1747 a second courthouse (or at least a newer model of the first) was
already in place.
5
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Second Courthouse
For convenience, we will refer to this 1745 courthouse as the second courthouse, which lasted until
1785 when it was taken by fire.
6
During the Revolutionary War, the State Legislature met here after the
British burned Kingston in 1777, making Poughkeepsie the de facto state capitol up through the US
Constitutional Ratification Convention in 1788.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1
L. 1715, Ch. 297; See Frank Hasbrouck, History of Dutchess County Vol. 1 (Higginson Book Co., 1909), 65.
2
Smith, supra at 336.
3
Ghee, J. Half Way Up the Hudson (Mount Pleasant, SC: Arcadia Publishing, 1997), 12.
4
Platt, E. The Eagle’s History of Poughkeepsie from Earliest Settlements, 1683 to 1905 (1905), 19-21.
5
Ghee, at 12; See also French, J.H. Gazetteer of the State of New York (Syracuse, NY: 1860), 268.
6
Smith, supra at 338. Ghee, supra at 12, dates the fire as April 1785.
8 07/07/2015
The Third (The Ratification) Courthouse
An Act dated April 11, 1785 ordered reconstruction of
the 1745 building.
7
This was accomplished in 1785-1787
in time for one of the most important events in
American history: New York’s ratification of the United
States Constitution, which took place there at the barely
completed courthouse in June-July 1788. Historian
Martha Lamb described the Ratification in Poughkeepsie:
“Thus turned the pivot in the history of the English-
speaking race.”
8
Some, but not all, might think it an
exaggeration.
This hallowed courthouse was consumed by fire on
September 25, 1806.
9
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Fourth Courthouse
By Act dated March 24, 1809, the authorities ordered
the construction of the fourth courthouse, which was
erected 1809-1811.
10
It endured in its Victorian beauty
until it was replaced by the fifth and current courthouse,
built 1902-1903. The 1809-1902 court house featured an
oyster bar run by Matthew Vassar, who went on to
found the college that bears his name.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7
Smith, supra at 102; Hasbrouck, supra at 66.
8
Lamb, M. History of the City of New York, Vol. 2, p. 321.
9
Hasbrouck, supra at 66; See also Ghee, supra at 14. According to Ms. Ghee, the 1792 drawing by Archibald Robertson (at
the New York Historical Society) is the only image of the so-called Ratification Courthouse of 1788.
10
Hasbrouck, supra at 66.
Courthouse 1809-1902
View of Poughkeepsie by Archibald Robertson,
September 2, 1796. The Courthouse is in the
center of the image.
9 07/07/2015
The fifth (current) Courthouse
Under the architectural design of William J. Beardsley,
this courthouse sits on the same site as its predecessors,
at the corner of Main and Market Streets in
Poughkeepsie. The County celebrated the courthouse
centennial in 2002-2003.
For further information, see generally “The Court House
of Dutchess County – First, Second, Third, and Fourth
Buildings, 1717- 1810” in Dutchess County Historical
Yearbook, 1938, Vol 23 p. 74-98. See also “The
Courthouse of Dutchess County, 1809-1901.” Dutchess
County Historical Society,1939, Vol. 24 p. 69-74.
In a publication entitled The Dutchess County Courthouse 100th Anniversary (Dutchess Co Bar Assoc.,
2002) there is a history of the courthouses with images of the first, second, third (artists or imaginings)
fourth, and fifth courthouses.
11
11
For further information, generally, see Historic Courthouses of New York State (H.A. Johnson, R.K. Andrist); Julia and
Albert Rosenblatt. Historic Courthouses of New York State (Turner Press, 2006); For courthouses in USA, see Richard Pare,
Court House, New York, 1978.
1902-1903 (present) Courthouse at right
10 07/07/2015
III. The Bench and The Bar
a. Judges
UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT
Thompson, Smith (1768-1843) – of Dutchess County, NY; Justice
of U.S. Supreme Court, 1823-43; candidate for Governor of New
York, 1828; state court judge in New York, 1802-14; U.S. Secretary
of the Navy, 1819-23. Buried in Poughkeepsie rural cemetery.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NEW YORK SUPREME COURT (Pre-1846)
Benson, Egbert (1746-1833) – of Red Hook, NY; New York State’s
first Attorney General, 1777-88; Member of New York State
Assembly from Dutchess County, 1777-81, 1788; Member,
Continental Congress from New York, 1784-1788; Member, New
York Constitutional Convention that Ratified the United States’
Constitution, 1788; U.S. Representative from New York, 1789-93,
1813 (3rd District 1789-93, 2nd District 1813); Justice of New York
Supreme Court, 1794-1801; Judge of U.S. Court of Appeals for the
2nd Circuit, 1801.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Smith Thompson, 1768-1843
Egbert Benson, 1746-1833
11 07/07/2015
Duer, William A. (1780-1858) – of Rhinebeck; Justice, Supreme Court of New York State, 1823-1829;
President Columbia University, 1829-1842.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Kent, James (1763-1847) – of Poughkeepsie, Dutchess County, NY;
Justice of New York Supreme Court, 1798, Chief Justice, 1804;
Chancellor of New York, 1814; Member of New York State
Assembly, 1790-91, 1792-93, 1796-97 (Dutchess County); Author
of Commentaries on American Law, the first comprehensive
treatment of the subject. Buried in Beacon, NY.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Lewis, Morgan (1754-1844) – of Rhinebeck, NY; Governor of
New York, 1804-07; New York State Attorney General, 1791-92;
member of New York State Assembly Dutchess County, 1791-92;
Justice of New York Supreme Court of Judicature, 1792-1803;
Member of New York State Senate Middle District, 1811-14;
General in the U.S. Army during the War of 1812.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
James Kent, 1763-1847
Morgan Lewis, 1754-1844
12 07/07/2015
Radcliff, Jacob (1764-1844) – Member, New York State Assembly, representing Dutchess County, 1795;
Assistant Attorney General, 1796; Justice, New York Supreme Court, 1798-1804; Mayor of New York
City, 1810-1811, 1815-1818.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NEW YORK COURT OF APPEALS
Ruggles, Charles Herman (1789-1865) – of Poughkeepsie; Chief Judge
of New York Court of Appeals, 1851-53; U.S. Representative from New
York 7th District, 1821-23; Delegate, to New York State Constitutional
Convention and Chairman of Judiciary Committee, 1846; Judge of New
York Court of Appeals, 1847-55.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rosenblatt, Albert (1936- ) – of La Grange/Pleasant Valley, NY;
Judge, Court of Appeals, 1999-2006; Justice, Appellate Division
Second Department 1989-1999; New York State Chief
Administrative Judge, 1987-1989; Justice of the New York
Supreme Court, 9th J.D., 1981-1998; County Judge, 1976-1981;
District Attorney, 1969-1975.
Charles Herman Ruggles, 1789-1865
13 07/07/2015
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPREME COURT, APPELLATE DIVISION
Aldrich, Raymond E. (1888-1947) – of Poughkeepsie, NY; Justice of New York Supreme Court 9th J.D.,
1934-47; Appellate Division, 2nd Department, 1944-1947.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Barnard, Joseph Folger (1823-1903) – Born in Nantucket, 1823, attended Old Dutchess Academy in
Poughkeepsie, followed by graduation from Yale College in 1841; Elected, New York Supreme Court,
1863; Re-elected 1871 and 1885; Presiding Justice General Term Second Department (Predecessor to
Appellate Division) 1888-1893; His full sized portrait is over the bench in the Dutchess County
Courthouse Ceremonial Courtroom second floor; The Barnard Memorial Library bears his name.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dillon, Mark (1959- ) – Justice of Supreme Court 9th J.D., 2000-present; Appellate Division, 2d
Department, 2005-present; County Court, Westchester County, 1997.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hawkins, Joseph (1916-1978) – of Poughkeepsie; Justice of the Supreme Court, 9th J.D., 1964-1978;
Appellate Division, 1976-1978.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jaycox, Walter Husted (1863-1927) – Born in Wassaic, NY; Suffolk County District Attorney, 1893-99;
Suffolk County Judge, 1902-05; Justice of New York Supreme Court 2nd District, 1905-1922; Appellate
Division, 1922-1927.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Marlow, George D. (1941- ) – Dutchess County Family Court, 1984-1992; County Court, Dutchess
County, 1993-1999; Supreme Court Justice 9th J.D., 2000-2009; Appellate Division, First Department,
2001-2008; Chair, NYS Advisory Comm. on Judicial Ethics, 1996-present.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rosenblatt, Albert, M. (1936- ) – See under Court of Appeals, above.
14 07/07/2015
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STATE COURT JUDGES
Bockee, Abraham (1784-1865) – Born in Shekomeko, Dutchess County; Member, New York State
Assembly, 1819-20; U.S. Representative from New York 5th District, 1829-31, 1833-37; Member New
York State Senate 2nd District, 1842-45; served as Senator on the New York Court for the Trial of
Impeachments and Correction of Errors , 1842-1845; County Court, Dutchess County, 1846.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dean, Gilbert (1819-1870) – of Pleasant Valley; U.S. Representative from New York, 1851-54 (8th
District, 1851-53, 12th District, 1853-54); Justice of New York Supreme Court, 2nd District, 1854-55; Ex-
officio service on the New York Court of Appeals, 1855; Member, New York State Assembly, 1863.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Emott, James (1771-1850) – Born in Poughkeepsie, NY March 9, 1771; U.S. Representative from New
York 4
th
District, 1809-13; Member, New York State Assembly, Albany: 1803-04, Dutchess: 1813-15,
1816-17; Justice, Supreme Court, New York, 2
nd
Circuit, 1827-1831.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Emott, James (1823-1884) – Justice, New York Supreme Court, 2
nd
Judicial District, 1855-1864;
Presiding Justice, 1863; ex officio New York Court of Appeals, 1863.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gildersleeve, Henry Alger (1840- 1923) – Born in Clinton, Dutchess County, NY; Colonel in the Union
Army during the Civil War; Judge of General Sessions, New York, 1876-89; Superior Court Judge, New
York, 1891-95; Justice of New York Supreme Court 1st District, 1896-1909.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mack, John E. (1874-1958) – of Poughkeepsie; Justice of New York Supreme Court 9th District, 1930;
delegate to Democratic National Convention from New York, 1940, 1944; Nominated Franklin D.
Roosevelt for President of the United States, 1932, 1936.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Platt, Jonas (1769-1834) – Born in Wappingers; Member, New York State Assembly, 1796; U.S.
Representative from New York 9th District, 1799-1801; Member, New York State Senate, (Western
District) 1810-12; Candidate for Governor of New York, 1810; Justice, New York Supreme Court of
Judicature, 1814-23; Wrote Gibbons v. Ogden for the Court for the Trial of Impeachments and
Correction of Errors, 1820; Member, New York State Constitutional Convention, 1821.
15 07/07/2015
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Platt, Zephaniah (1735-1807) – Of Poughkeepsie Platt family, founders of Plattsburgh, NY; Member,
Provincial Congress, 1775-1777; Member of New York State Senate Middle District, 1777-83; County
Judge, Dutchess County, 1781-1795; Delegate, Continental Congress, 1784; Delegate, New York
Convention to Ratify U.S. constitution, 1788.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Westbrook, Theodoric Romeyn (1821-1885) – Born in Fishkill, NY; U.S. Representative from New York
11th District, 1853-55; Justice, New York Supreme Court, 3rd J.D.,1873-1885.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPREME COURT JUSTICES, 9
TH
JUDICIAL DISTRICT
The Ninth Judicial District is composed of the counties of Westchester, Dutchess, Orange, Rockland,
and Putnam. The following were Dutchess County Resident Supreme Court Justices.
1906-1930 Joseph Morschauser
1930 John E. Mack
1934-1947 Raymond E. Aldrich
(Appellate Division 1944-
1947)
1948-1955 J. Gordon Flannery
1965-1978 Joseph F. Hawkins (Appellate
Division 1976-1978)
1966-1971 Leonard L. Supple
1969-1975 W. Vincent Grady
1976-1997 Joseph Jiudice
1978-1981 Joseph D. Quinn
1982-1999 Albert M. Rosenblatt
(Appellate Division 1989 -
1999)
1984-2002 Ralph A. Beisner
1992-2000 Judith Hillery
2000-present Mark C. Dillon (Appellate
Division 2005-present)
2000-2008 George D. Marlow (Appellate
Division 2001-2008)
2003-present James V. Brands
2003-present Christine A. Sproat
2013-present Maria G. Rosa
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
COUNTY COURT JUDGES
1716 Leonard Lewis
1739 Jacob Terboss
1749 Martinus Hoffman
1755 Jacob Terboss
1769 Beverly Robinson
1778 Ephraim Paine
1781 Zephaniah Platt
1795 David Brooks
16 07/07/2015
1807 John Johnstone
1817 James Emott
1823 Marturin Livingston
1828 Daniel C. Ver Planck
1830 Edmund H. Pendleton
1840 Joseph I. Jackson
1845 Seward Barculo
1846 Abraham Bockee
1846 John Rowley
1
1847 John Rowley
1851 Egbert Q. Eldridge
1855 Homer A. Nelson
1859 Homer A. Nelson
1863 Charles Wheaton
2
1866 Allard Anthony
1872 Henry M. Taylor
1878 Benjamin Platt Carpenter
1884 Daniel W. Guernsey
1890 Daniel W. Guernsey
1896 Samuel K. Phillips
1902 Samuel K. Phillips
1908-1913 Frank Hasbrouck
1914-1930 Charles W.H. Arnold
1931-1947 J. Gordon Flannery
(Children’s Court, 1931)
1
Office made elective in 1846
2
Appointed after Nelson resigned
1948-1965 John R. Schwartz
1966-1968 Raymond C. Baratta
1966-1975 Joseph Jiudice
1970-1982 Raymond E. Aldrich
1976-1981 Albert M. Rosenblatt
1982 Bernard Kessler
1983-1991 Judith Hillery
1985-1992 John R. King
1993-2010 Thomas J. Dolan
1993-1999 George D. Marlow
2000-2010 Gerald V. Hayes
2011-present Peter M. Forman
2011-present Stephen L. Greller
17 07/07/2015
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SURROGATES
1778 Gilbert Livingston
1785 Anthony Hoffman
1787 Gilbert Livingston
1804 James Tallmadge, Jr.
1810 Thomas J. Oakley
1811 George Bloom
1813 Philo Ruggles
1815 Derrick B. Stockholm
1819 John Brush
1821 Ebenezer Nye
1828 James Hooker
1840 Robert Wilkinson
1844 Virgil D. Bonesteel
1847 John P. H. Tallman
1855 Edgar Thorn
1860 Peter Dorland
1866 Milton A. Fowler
1872 Peter Dorland
1878 Collins Sheldon
1884 Horace D. Hufcut
1884 Daniel W. Guernsey (County
Judge Acting Surrogate)
1890 Cyrenus P. Dorland
1896 Cyrenus P. Dorland
1902 Willet E. Hoysradt
1908 Charles (Collins?) A. Hopkins
1914-1942 Daniel J. Gleason
1927 Charles W.H. Arnold
1942 John R. Schwartz, Jr. (District
Attorney Acting Surrogate)
1941-1942 J. Gordon Flannery
1942 Edward V. Mack
1942-1943 Stanley M. Vincent
1943 Frederick S. Quinterro
1951 W. Vincent Grady
1970 Raymond C. Baratta
1983 James D. Benson
1993 George G. Bernhard
1999-present James D. Pagones
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FAMILY COURT JUDGES
1961 Joseph Jiudice (Children’s
Court)
1962 New York voters approved a
State Constitutional
amendment creating the
Family Court (NY Const. Art.
IV, Sec 13)
1964-1966 Joseph Jiudice
1966-1969 Raymond E. Aldrich
1969-1978 John R. Heilman, Jr.
1972-1992 George D. Bernhard
1979-1982 Judith Hillery
1984-1992 George D. Marlow
1989-2008 Damian J. Amodeo
18 07/07/2015
1993-1998 James D. Pagones
1994-2002 James V. Brands
1999-2010 Peter M. Forman
2003-2013 Valentino T. Sammarco
2009-present Joan S. Posner
2012-present Denise M. Watson
2014-present Joseph A. Egitto
19 07/07/2015
b. Attorneys and District Attorneys
PRESIDENT AND GOVERNORS
Roosevelt, Franklin Delano (1882-1945) – Born in Hyde Park, NY;
Governor of New York, 1929-33; President of the United States, 1933-
45.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dewey, Thomas E. (1902-1971) – Of Pawling, NY; Governor of New
York, 1943-1954; Republican Presidential candidate 1944, 1948.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Lewis, Morgan (1754-1844) – Of Rhinebeck, NY; Governor of New York, 1804-07); See under Supreme
Court.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Franklin D. Roosevelt, 1882-1945 & the Roosevelt Estate, Hyde Park, NY
Thomas E. Dewey, 1902-1971 & Dapplemere Farm, the Dewey Residence in Pawling
20 07/07/2015
ATTORNEYS
Bailey, Theodorus (1758-1828) – Born near Fishkill, NY; U.S. Senator from New York, 1803-04;
Postmaster, New York City, 1804-28; U.S. Representative from New York 5th District, 1793-97, 1799-
1801, 1801-03; Member, New York State Assembly from Dutchess County, 1801-02.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Brush, Henry (1778-1855) – Born in Dutchess County, NY June, 1778; Justice of Ohio State Supreme
Court, 1830-31.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Carpenter, Benjamin Platt (1837-1921) – Born in Stanford, Dutchess County, NY; Dutchess County
District Attorney, 1858; Delegate to New York State Constitutional Convention, 1867-68; Delegate,
Republican National Convention from New York, 1868, 1872, 1884; Member New York State Senate
11th District, 1876-77; Dutchess County Judge, 1878-83; New York Republican State Chair, 1881-82;
Candidate for Lieutenant Governor of New York, 1882; Governor of Montana Territory, 1884- 1885.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chanler, Lewis Stuyvesant (1869-1942) – Of Barrytown, Dutchess County, NY; Lieutenant Governor of
New York, 1907-08; Candidate for Governor of New York, 1908; Member, New York State Assembly
from Dutchess County 2nd District, 1910-12.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Coffin, Owen Vincent (1836-1921) – Born in Union Vale, Dutchess County, NY; Governor of
Connecticut, 1895-97; Mayor of Middletown, Conn., 1872-73.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Corliss, Guy Carleton Haynes (b. 1858) – Born in Poughkeepsie, Dutchess County, NY; Justice of North
Dakota Supreme Court, 1889-98; Dean, Law School, University of North Dakota, 1899-1902.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Drake, John Reuben (1782-1857) – Born in Pleasant Valley, NY; County Judge, Broome County, 1815-
23; Court of Common Pleas, Tioga County, 1833-1838; U.S. Representative from New York 15th
District, 1817-19; Member, New York State Assembly, 1834.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Emmet, William Colville (1836-1901) – Born in Dutchess County, NY; U.S. Charge d'Affaires to Turkey,
1885; U.S. Consul in Smyrna, 1886-93; Aix-la-Chapelle, 1893-97.
21 07/07/2015
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Eno, Stephen (1764-1854) – practiced law in Pine Plains, opening an office there in 1815, followed by
his son William Eno (1800-1874) and grandsons William Stewart Eno (1827-1902) and Frank Eno (1845-
1933). The Eno law office is one of the oldest free standing professional buildings in New York State
and beyond. The office is occasionally open to the public.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Farrington, Walter J. (b. 1829) – of Fishkill, NY; Born in Lagrangeville, Dutchess County, NY; Prohibition
candidate for Chief Judge of New York Court of Appeals, 1892; Prohibition candidate for New York
State Attorney General, 1873; Prohibition candidate for U.S. Representative from New York, 1874 (13th
District), 1886 (16th District); Prohibition candidate for Judge of New York Court of Appeals, 1884,
1889; Prohibition candidate for New York State Senate 16th District, 1893; Candidate for Justice of
New York Supreme Court, 1896 (Prohibition, 2nd District), 1915 (9th District).
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fish, Hamilton, Jr. (1926-1996) – Of Millbrook, Dutchess County; U.S. Representative from New York,
1969-95 (28th District, 1969-73, 25th District, 1973-83, 21st District, 1983-93, 19th District, 1993-95);
Delegate, Republican National Convention from New York.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Forrestal, James Vincent (1892-1949) – Of Beacon, Dutchess County, NY; U.S. Secretary of the Navy,
1944-47; U.S. Secretary of Defense, 1947-49.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
John J. Gartland, Jr. (1914-2003) – Of Poughkeepsie, NY; attorney,
partner, Corbally, Gartland, and Rappleyea; President, McCann
Foundation, a civic philanthropic organization; Co-trustee, Cuneen-
Hackett Foundation; Chairman, Board of Trustees, Marist College,
1972-1974; Trustee, St. Francis Hospital, 1965-1982, Chairman, 1971-
1973; Major, U.S. Army Air Corp., 1942, 1945; Law Secretary to
Federal SDNY Judge Edward A. Conger, 1939-1942. His firm evolved
from the firm of Hackett and Williams, founded in 1876, with
members James L. Williams and John T. Hackett, and later, City Judge
Charles J. Corbally.
John J. Gartland, Jr., 1914-2003
22 07/07/2015
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
German, Obadiah (1766-1842) – Born in Amenia, NY; U.S. Senator from New York, 1809-15.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Greene, Thurston (1907- 2009) – Of Millbrook; After his graduation from Williams College and Harvard
Law School, he was the first lawyer hired by Thomas E. Dewey for his corruption prosecution team in
1935, and its last surviving member at age 101; United States Air force, WWII; Author, The Language of
the Constitution, 1991.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Herrick, Samuel (1779-1852) – Born in Amenia, NY; U.S. Attorney for Ohio, 1810-18, 1829-30; U.S.
Representative from Ohio 4th District, 1817-21; Presidential Elector for Ohio, 1828.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Johnson, Jeh (1957- ) – Raised in Wappinger Falls, NY; Current head of the United States Secretary of
Homeland Security; General Counsel of the Department of Defense, 2009-2012, during the first Obama
Administration; Graduate of Morehouse College (B.A.) and Columbia Law School (J.D.); grandson of
sociologist and Fisk University president Dr. Charles S. Johnson.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ketcham, John Henry (1832-1906) – Of Dover Plains, NY; Member, New York State Assembly from
Dutchess County 1st District, 1856-57; Member of New York State Senate 11th District, 1860-61;
General, Union Army during the Civil War; U.S. Representative from New York, 1865-73, 1877-93,
1897-1906 (12th District, 1865-73, 13th District, 1877-85, 16th District, 1885-93, 18th District, 1897-
1903, 21st District, 1903-06); Delegate, Republican National Convention from New York, 1876, 1896.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Latimer, George (b. 1935) – Born in Poughkeepsie, NY; Mayor of St. Paul, Minn., 1976-90.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
LeRoy, Daniel (1775-1858) – Born in Poughkeepsie, NY; U.S. Attorney for Michigan, 1826-34; Michigan
State Attorney General, 1836-37.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Livingston, Gilbert (1742-1806) – Delegate, Constitutional Ratification Convention, 1788; New York
Provincial Congress, 1775; Member, New York State Assembly, 1777-1778, 1788-1789; Anti-Slavery
Manumission Society, 1787; Surrogate, Dutchess County,1787-1785; 1787-1794.
23 07/07/2015
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Livingston, Peter Robert (1766-1847) – Born in Rhinebeck, NY; Lieutenant Governor of New York,
1828; Member of New York State Senate, 1815-22, 1826-29 (Southern District, 1815-22, 2nd District,
1826-29); Member, New York State Assembly from Dutchess County, 1823; Speaker, New York State
Assembly, 1823; Delegate, Whig National Convention from New York, 1839 (Convention Vice-
President).
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nelson, Homer Augustus (1829-1891) – Of Poughkeepsie, NY; Secretary of State of New York, 1868-71;
Dutchess County Judge, 1855-62; U.S. Representative from New York 12
th
District, 1863-65; Delegate,
New York State Constitutional Convention, 1867; Member, New York State Senate 15
th
District, 1882-
83.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Oakley, Thomas Jackson (1783-1857) – Of Poughkeepise, NY; Surrogate, Dutchess County, 1810-1811;
New York State Attorney General, 1819-21; Superior Court Judge, New York City, 1828-57, Chief Judge ,
1847-1857; U.S. Representative from New York, 1813-15, 1827-28 (4th District, 1813-15, 5th District,
1827-28); Member of New York State Assembly from Dutchess County, 1815-16.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ostertag, Robert L. – Partner, Ostertag O’Leary Barrett and Faulkner Guernsey Butts Ostertag &
O’Leary, Esqs. (Formerly Guernsey, Butts & Walsh), Poughkeepsie, New York, 1960 – 1995; President,
New York State Bar Association, 1991-1992; New York Lawyers Deskbook, Chairman, Editorial Board,
NY State Bar Association, 1989; U.S. Air Force, Bangor, Maine, Judge Advocate, 1956 – 1958; Chief
Counsel’s Office, Internal Revenue Service, Washington, D.C., 1958-1960.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pendleton, Nathaniel (1756-1821) – United States District Judge, District of Georgia, 1789-1796; Law
practice in Dutchess County (possibly also County Judge); died in Hyde Park. In 1804, he served as a
“second” to Alexander Hamilton in his duel with Aaron Burr.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Quitman, John Anthony (1799-1858) – Born in Rhinebeck, NY; Governor of Mississippi, 1835-36, 1850-
51; State Court Judge in Mississippi, 1838; General in the U.S. Army during the Mexican War; Candidate
for Democratic nomination for Vice President, 1848, 1856; Presumed to have been deliberately
poisoned at a banquet during the inauguration of President James Buchanan, in Washington, D.C.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
24 07/07/2015
Rolison, Jay P. Jr. (1929-2007) – Member, New York State Senate, 1967-1990; Assistant majority
leader, 1985; Of Counsel, McCabe and Mack.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Saland, Stephen M. (1943- ) – Member, New York State Senate, 1991-2012 (41st District); New York
State Assembly, 1980-1990 (99th District); Of Counsel, Gellert, Klein & MacLeod.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Schell, Augustus (1812-1884) – Born in Rhinebeck, NY; New York Democratic State Chair, 1853-55;
Delegate, Democratic National Convention from New York, 1856, 1860, 1876 (speaker); U.S. Collector
of Customs, 1857-61; candidate for Mayor of New York City, 1878.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Smith, Melancton (1744-1798) – Of Charlotte Precinct Dutchess County, NY; Continental Army
Revolutionary War; Delegate, Continental Congress from New York, 1785-87; Delegate, New York
Convention to Ratify U.S. Constitution from Dutchess County, 1788; member of New York State
Assembly from New York County, 1791-92.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tallmadge, James, Jr. (1778-1853) – Born in Stanford, Dutchess County, NY; President of New York
University, 1830-46; Lieutenant Governor of New York, 1828; U.S. Representative from New York 4th
District, 1817-19; Delegate, New York State Constitutional Convention, 1821; Member, New York State
Assembly from Dutchess County, 1824; Delegate, New York State Constitutional Convention, 1846.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tendy, William M. (1954-2014) – Of Hyde Park, NY; son of Anna Appignani and William Tendy, Sr., (d.
1986) who had been Acting US Attorney for the Southern District of NY; Assistant District Attorney, NY
County 1979-1983; noted Dutchess County trial attorney, most particularly for his defense, in 1998, of
a 38-year-old Black Jamaican immigrant, saving him from the death penalty. Presiding at the trial,
Judge George D. Marlow later called Tendy’s summation the most brilliant and moving he had ever
heard. (See “Public Lives: Lawyer Wins Battle of his Client’s Life,” NY Times, Aug. 5, 1998).
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Van Tuyl, Jennifer – Dutchess County’s first female assistant district attorney (1971-1976); Attorney,
Village of Cold Spring, 1977-1985, Town of East Fishkill, 1982–; Town of Fishkill Planning Board, 1984-
1988; President, Dutchess County Bar Assoc. 1987; Member, New York State Advisory Committee on
Land Use Statutes; Chair, Committee on Growth Management.in Governor's Commission on Coastal
Resources.
25 07/07/2015
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DISTRICT ATTORNEYS
1796
1
Jacob Radcliff
1801 Smith Thompson
1810 Randall S. Street
1813 Randall S. Street
1815 George Bloom
1818 George Bloom
1819 Philo Riggles
1821 Francis A. Livingston (1821-
1829?)
1826 Stephen Cleveland
1836 George A. Schufeldt
1843 E. M. Swift
1845 William Eno
1847 Joseph T. Lee
1849 James Emott, Jr.
2
1849 Thomas C. Campbell
1855 Silas Wodell
1858 Benjamin Platt Carpenter
1860 Allard Anthony
3
1865 Allard Anthony
1868 William I. Thorn
1871 Tristram Coffin
1874 James L. Williams
1
List of Pre-1930 names taken largely from Hasbrouck,
77.
2
Appointed after Lee deceased.
3
Appointed after Carpenter resigned, elected in 1861.
1877 William R. Woodin
1880 William R. Woodin
1883 John Hackett
1886 John Hackett
1889 Martin Heermance
1892 Horace D. Hufcut
1895 George Wood
1898 George Wood
1901 William R. Lee
1904 William R. Lee
1907 John E. Mack
1912 Edward A. Conger
1916 Raymond Aldrich
1922 Allen S. Reynolds
1931 John R. Schwartz, Jr
1945 Ely L. Gellert
1947 W. Vincent Grady
1951 Raymond C. Baratta
1967 John R. Heilman Jr.
1969 Albert M. Rosenblatt
1976 John R. King
1984-present William V. Grady
26 07/07/2015
c. Dutchess County Bar Association
PRESIDENTS
1919-1927 Frank B. Lown
1928 Frank Hasbrouck
1929 Frederick Barnard
1930 George Overocker
1931 John J. Mylod
1932 CWH Arnold
1933 Ralph A. Butts
1934 Elijah T. Russell
1935 Charles A. Hopkins
1936 Joseph A. Daughton
1937 Harry C. Barker
1938 Edward C. Conger
1939 John B. Grubb
1940 Raymond Guernsey
1941 Everett H. Travis
James E. Carroll
1942 J. Gordon Flannery
1943 John R. Schwartz
1944 Charles J. Corbally
1945 Gauis C. Bolin, Sr.
1946 Leonard Supple
1947 William Mulvey
1948 Robert W. Doughty
1949 Archibald Mackennan
1950 Alexander Dow
1951 John B. VanDeWater
1952 William Duggan
1953 Joseph A. McCabe
1954 Benson Frost
1955 David McCullough
1956 Earl Hawley
1957 Charles O’Donnell
1958 Arthur Halpin
1959 James Aspbury
1960 Frederick Heaney
1961 Lloyd Rosenthal
1962 R. Donald Slee
1963 Ely Gellert
1964 W. Vincent Grady
1965 Nathaniel Rubin
1966 John A. Reed
1967 John J. Mulvey
1968 Charles Butts
1969 Edward J. Kovacs
1970 John Palisi
1971 Joseph H. Gellert
1972 William J. Walsh
1973 Robert J. Marvin
1974 Joseph C. McCabe
1975 Herman A. Levine
1976 Peter C. McGinnis
1977 Milton M. Haven
1978 John B. Garrity
1979 Edward Rosen
1980 Harold L. Mangold
1981 John A. Wolf
1982 Charlotte M. Frank
1983 Arthur Gellert
1984 Robert Ostertag
1985 Jack Economou
27 07/07/2015
1986 Hon. Damian J. Amodeo
1987 Jennifer L. Van Tuyl
1988 J. Joseph McGowan
1989 John Gifford
1990 Paul Banner
1991 Hon. George Marlow
1992 Lou Lewis
1993 Paul Goldstein
1994 Chester Gordon
1995 Frank Redl
1996 Donald Brown
1997 Jessica Vinall
1998 Michael Kranis
1999 Fred Schaeffer
2000 John Basso
2001 Hon. Maria Rosa
2002 Lance Portman
2003 Hon. Christine A. Sproat
2004 Marty Rutberg
2005 Kyle Barnett
2006 Bryan Schneider
2007 Brian Morgan
2008 Richard Fiorile
2009 Maura Barrett
2010 Hon. Peter M. Forman
2011 Rebecca Valk
2012 Daniel McCabe
2013 Hon. Jonah Triebwasser
2014 Hon. Frank M. Mora
Pictures of Bar Presidents from 1919 to 1989 appear in the “Dutchess County Bar Association 70
th
Anniversary” publication
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS
Marie Meehan Komisar (1981-1999)
Heidi Bourbeau (1998-2003)
Mark Fedorchak (2003-2004)
Janna DeVito Whearty (2004-present)
For many years, before the executive directorship, Poughkeepsie attorney Herbert Davis, in his position
as Bar Secretary, managed a great deal of the day-to-day operations of the Associations.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
BAR ASSOCIATION RESOURCES
1
American Bar Association. State and Local Bar Associations, December 1, 1929. Listing Dutchess County
bar officers.
Corbally Gartland & Rappleyea One Hundred Year History (Private publication)
1
In 1994, a fire took the records of the Dutchess County Bar Association, and so what we have is pieced together from
secondary sources.
28 07/07/2015
Corning, A., Emsley, J. and Jewell, W. Southeastern New York, A History of the Counties of Ulster,
Dutchess, Orange, Rockland, and Putnam (Lewis Historical Publishing: New York, NY, 1946). Contains a
chapter entitled “Dutchess Political Life” describing the Dutchess County bar.
Dutchess County Bar Association. 70th Anniversary (1989) publication
36 pages, of bar history and pictures
Picture of lawyer’s row buildings, 1885
Picture of minutes of first meeting of the County bar, 1919
Pictures of 1935 constitution and by-laws; 1936 annual meeting
Pictures of 1938 picnic and roll of attorneys c. 1946
Pictures of Dutchess County Bar Presidents, 1919-1989
List of 50 year members in 1989. The originals of these documents were destroyed in a fire
several years ago.
The Dutchess County Bar Association. “The Dutchess County Bar Association 1919-2002,” in The
Dutchesss County Courthouse 100th Anniversary (2002).
The Dutchess County Bar Association. 75
th
Anniversary (1919-1994), 16 pp.
Dutchess County Bar Association Group Photographs at the Dutchess County Courthouse
For 1900, 1924, 1948, 1969, 1977, 1981, 1997, 2003 and 2009.
These bar group photos are virtually the only source of bar membership for the years before
1994 when the Bar Association records were consumed in a fire.
Lown, F. “The Bench and Bar of Dutchess County,” in History of Dutchess County New York, Vol. 2, by
Hasbrouck, F. (Poughkeepsie, NY: S.A. Mathieu, 1909), 498-527. This is the most complete early
history.
Marshall, N. McCabe and Mack, The Early History of a Dutchess County Law Firm. Available at
http://www.mccm.com/history/
Poughkeepsie New Yorker, May 24, 1959 issue. With bar history.
Taylor, C.J. Eminent Members of the Bench and Bar of New York. (San Francisco: Knight-Counihan,
1943), 54.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The 70
th
Anniversary publication of the Dutchess County Bar Association (1998) offers this:
1919 The Birth of the Bar Association
One winter's day in late December 1919, lawyers of Dutchess County gathered to put
the final touches on the documents that would formally create a county Bar Association.
Around them, America was changing, a country being pulled by both the past and the
future. A great war had just been won; an uneasy peace was just beginning. Prohibition
was about to become the law of the land. Coal miners and cops walked picket lines. The
Harvard football team was in Pasadena for the Rose Bowl. Lenin was in Moscow
29 07/07/2015
consolidating a revolution. And the new heavyweight champion of the world was a
young puncher named Jack Dempsey.
The new Bar Association’s roster that day contained the names of 128 lawyers. Only one
of them – Anna G. Dayley – was a woman. Gains C. Bolan Sr. was the only black
attorney. Twenty-five years later, at the end of another war, he would become
president of the organization.
To read through that roster is to understand how much the legal profession mirrored
America's transition. Men like Frank B. Lown and Stephen G. Guernsey were born in
rural Dutchess County and came to Poughkeepsie to learn the law by working as clerks
for established attorneys. A growing number of the others had come to the profession
by way of college and law school, Henry T. Hackett had attended Harvard College and
New York University Law School before joining his father's firm. William L. Gellert
graduated in the class of 1895 at Cornell's law school.
In many ways, the very idea of forming a local association was part of a larger
movement afoot in the country: the "professionalization" of certain occupations by
establishing uniform standards of conduct and the establishment of entrance
requirements. Under the Dutchess County Bar Association’s first constitution and
bylaws, membership was not automatic for attorneys. Membership required the
approval of the Committee on Admissions – two "No" votes and he was out of
consideration – as well as the approval of 80 percent of the Association's voting
members.
Not surprisingly, the grievance procedure for adjudicating complaints against
Association members takes up two of the eight pages of the bylaws.
The early 1900s was also a time of growth for the legal profession nationwide.
According to UCLA legal historian Richard Abel, with the number of lawyers climbing
steadily until the onset of the Depression, it was a growth fueled in large part by the
arrival of immigrants, first into public schools and then into the profession.
Vincent diGennaro, born in Italy in 1900, and now the oldest member of the Association,
recalls being one of the few professionals of Italian descent in the Mid-Hudson region
when he began his practice in 1925. The son of a tailor with a shop on Raymond Avenue,
diGennaro arrived in America at age 14. He was promptly placed in the first grade
because he did not speak English. Eleven years later, he graduated from the Fordham
University Law School.
But as much as the profession expanded, the differences with today's practice of law
remain striking. In 1920, the U.S. had 122,519 lawyers, or one for every 863 people. At
present, there is one for every 415, with the head count topping 725,000.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Legacy of Law: From Chancellor Kent to The Law Mill:
The man the members of the new Bar Association chose to be their first president was
uniquely qualified to understand the changing face of the lawyer's life. When he
30 07/07/2015
assumed his duties as Association president, Frank B. Lown was 70 years old. He had
practiced law in Dutchess County courtrooms for more than 40 years. Ten years earlier,
he had written a brief history of the county's legal profession.
"Time marches rapidly," he wrote, "and the lawyers of one generation, except they be
of remarkable ability and achievement, are forgotten by the next."
Lown had begun his legal education in the Poughkeepsie firm of Nelson and Baker in
1870. In those days before Holmes, Hand, and Cardozo, no American legal authority
carried as much weight.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
31 07/07/2015
d. Women Attorneys
Anna G.W. Daley (1868-1945) – The first woman attorney in Dutchess County. She was admitted to
practice at age 37 in 1905. She was a graduate of St. Mary’s School, Poughkeepsie High School, and
Eastman College (See generally The Dutchess County Courthouse 100th Anniversary, (2002), 9;
Poughkeepsie Knights of Columbus Fraternal News, Apr. 26, 1902; and Dec. 1905; Poughkeepsie Sunday
Courier, Sept. 14, 1924.)
Gov. Alfred E. Smith endorsed her for the State Assembly in 1924,
2
but she was defeated along with
every other Democratic party candidate.
3
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
History of the Mid-Hudson Women’s Bar Association
Article by Lisa Rubenstein and Juliana Maugeri
A HERSTORY
If you ask any female attorney who was admitted to practice in the 1970s or early
1980s, she is likely to tell you a story of disrespectful judges and male colleagues. She
may tell you about the humiliating experience of being asked at a calendar call if she
was really an attorney. She may even describe the uncomfortable experience of having
male attorneys fill the courtroom to listen to her argue a motion. You may laugh, but
female attorneys were a rarity in Dutchess, Ulster, Putnam and surrounding counties
and were the object of curiosity and often, disapproval.
Statewide, there were no committees on gender bias in the courts, no recourse for
sexual harassment, and few women Judges. Many female attorneys believed that local
bar associations failed to address their particular problems and concerns. Therefore,
these women sought the support and community of other female attorneys. As women
throughout New York began, in 1980, to organize the Women’s Bar Association of the
State of New York, female attorneys in Dutchess and Ulster counties also found strength
in numbers.
Efforts locally began with informal meetings at individual homes to compare notes, to
discuss concerns and to get support from other women facing similar issues in the legal
profession. One of the participants described these meetings as “consciousness-raising.”
Eventually, the group coalesced into a larger, more organized force, and in 1982 the
Mid-Hudson Women’s Bar Association was born as a chapter of the Women’s Bar
Association of the State of New York. The first formal meeting and election of officers
took place on July 15, 1982 at Elizabeth Shequine’s farm in Millbrook, New York.
Elizabeth Shequine (now a Town Justice) was elected the first president of the Board of
Directors. Forty-eight men and women counted themselves as members that first year.
2
Poughkeepsie Sunday Courier, Nov 2, 1924.
3
Poughkeepsie New Yorker, Obituary, January 23, 1945; Rosenblatt, A. "Pioneering Attorney Drew Little Attention"
Poughkeepsie Journal, Nov. 14, 1999.
32 07/07/2015
The purpose of the Women’s Bar Association and, in turn, the Mid-Hudson Chapter, was
to network, to organize and to advance the status of women. The Mid-Hudson Chapter’s
Board of Directors included a delegate to the Women’s Bar Association of the State of
New York so that a local voice could be heard at the state level. Although some Mid-
Hudson members were involved only on the local level, many members became
involved with the state organization, which gained significant input on legislation in
Albany and has used its efforts to increase the number of women in the judiciary.
Throughout its 30-year existence, the Mid-Hudson Women’s Bar Association has
continued to be a group of attorneys dedicated to networking, supporting and
mentoring other women. Members were interested and concerned not only about their
own professional status but also about the treatment of women in general. Our
Chapter’s members supported, with financial and legal assistance, organizations such as
Grace Smith House, Inc. and The Transitions Program of the Junior League, a program
designed to help divorced women.
More recently, our chapter has continued to serve the community and women in
general; participating in breast cancer awareness events such as Making Strides of the
Hudson Valley and hosting of heart health educational programming. We have
sponsored “Attire to Aspire” Dress for Success programs, which is a program to collect
donated professional clothing for disadvantaged women re-entering the work force. Our
chapter has also awarded scholarships to law students, donated money to women-
oriented charities and co-hosted a Law Day Legal Clinic for the local community. The
Chapter has also sponsored numerous continuing education programs on topics such as
real estate, matrimonial law, criminal law, bankruptcy, ethics, elder law and domestic
violence.
The annual Judges’ Cocktail Party was a well-attended event in the 1980s. The party was
designed to provide an opportunity for members to meet Judges on an informal basis.
The Judges’ Cocktail Party has now transformed into a Bench Meets Bar Dinner, a well-
attended annual staple of the organization.
The Mid-Hudson Chapter of the Women’s Bar Association has also awarded, on an
occasional basis, The Sojourner Truth Award, to a person who has promoted and
furthered the interests of women in the legal profession or who has furthered issues of
importance to all women. This award has been presented in past years to long time
members Karen Peters, now the first presiding female Justice in the Appellate Division,
Third Department; to founding member Judith Reichler (formerly a Town Justice) for her
role in drafting the Child Support Standards Act, which re-defined child support in New
York State; and to founding member and first president of our chapter, Justice Elizabeth
Shequine.
As the Mid-Hudson Women’s Bar Association celebrates its 30th Anniversary with more
than 100 members, the organization continues to have a lively agenda based on local
and statewide issues of concern. As the years pass, there is frequent re-examination of
the original purpose and current role of our Chapter. The Mid-Hudson Women’s Bar
Association remains a place where women lawyers are welcome to meet and support
each other, to discuss issues concerning all women and to use our influence to effect
33 07/07/2015
legislative and judicial change. While stories of disrespectful colleagues and
discrimination are less frequent than 30 years ago, we believe there is still a need for
our unique voice.
For more information, please visit our website @ www.mhwba.org or “like us” (Mid-
Hudson Women’s Bar Association) on Facebook.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
34 07/07/2015
e. African American Attorneys
Jane Matilda Bolin LL.B. (1908 –2007) – America’s first African-American woman to become a judge.
Born and raised in Poughkeepsie, she was the first African-American woman to graduate from Yale Law
School, the first to join the New York City Bar Association, and the first to join the New York City Law
Department. She became the first black woman to serve as a judge in the United States when she was
sworn into the bench of the New York City Domestic Relations Court in 1939.
Bolin was educated at high school in Poughkeepsie, and was one of two black students in her class at
Wellesley College in Massachusetts. She was the first African-American woman to receive a law degree
from Yale in 1931 and passed the New York state bar examination in 1932. She practiced with her
father, Gaius Bolin, in Poughkeepsie for a short period, and then with her first husband, Ralph E.
Mizelle. (See New York Times Obituary, January 10, 2007; see also, McLoed, J. Daughter of the Empire
State, The Life of Judge Jane Bolin (University of Illinois Press: 2011).)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gaius Charles Bolin (1864-1946) – First African-American attorney in Dutchess County; President of the
Dutchess County Bar Association. Pictured in the 1924 Dutchess County Bar Association composite.
Father of Judge Jane Bolin, above. Graduated from Poughkeepsie High School 1889, and the first
African American graduate of Williams College. After working as an associate in the law office of
Poughkeepsie attorney Fred Ackerman, Bolin opened his own practice at 46-48 Market St. in
Poughkeepsie. His son, Gaius C. Bolin, Jr was also a Poughkeepsie attorney.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
35 07/07/2015
f. Current Judiciary (2015)
Supreme Court: James V. Brands
Christine A. Sproat
Maria G. Rosa
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
County Court: Peter M. Forman
Stephen L. Greller
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Surrogate’s Court: James D. Pagones
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Family Court: Joan A. Posner
Denise M. Watson
Joseph A. Egitto
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
City Court:
Poughkeepsie: Katherine A. Moloney
Frank M. Mora
Beacon: Timothy G. Pagones
Rebecca Mensch
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Town and Village Justices: (alphabetical)
R. Wren Abrams, Town of Dover
Christi J. Acker, Town of Pine Plains
Bruce M. Aubin, Town of Washington, Village of
Millbrook
Paul L. Banner, Town of Poughkeepsie
Paul Caltagirone, Town of Pleasant Valley
Raymond C. Chase, Jr., Village of Wappingers
Falls
Francis G. Christensen, Town of Milan
Howard F. Clark, Village of Tivoli
John D. Crodelle, Town of North East
Taren Cummings, Village of Pawling
David E. Daniels, Jr., Town of Pawling
James Devine, Town of Amenia
Harold D. Epstein, Town of Fishkill
36 07/07/2015
Robert D. Ferris, Town of Beekman
John Fusco, Town of Dover
John C. Garito, Town of Beekman
Michael Hayes, Town of LaGrange
Louis W. Imperato, Town of Pine Plains
Raymond P. Jurina, Jr., Town of Union Vale
John Kane, Jr., Town & Village of Rhinebeck
John M. Kennedy, Town of Hyde Park
Heather L. Kitchen, Town of Wappinger
Kenneth J. Kremenick, Town of Milan
John D. Ludwig, Village of Tivoli
Jeffrey C. Martin, Town of Red Hook
Jeffrey Martin, Village of Red Hook
Michael Martin, Village of Fishkill
Irene McAliney, Town of East Fishkill
Casey McCabe, Town of North East
Norman Moore, Town of Amenia
Stephen P. O’Hare, Town of LaGrange
Paul S., Pancio, Town of Union Vale
Robert J. Rahemba, Town of Fishkill
Frederick Romig, Town of East Fishkill
William Sanchez, Town & Village of Rhinebeck
David A. Sears, Town of Pleasant Valley
Barbara Seelbach, Town of Clinton
Elizabeth K. Shequine, Town of Washington &
Village of Millbrook
Dennis Smith, Town of Stanford
David L. Steinberg, Town of Hyde Park
Paul O. Sullivan, Town of Poughkeepsie
Joseph Todaro, Village of Wappingers Falls
Russell D. Tompkins, Town of Clinton
Jonah Triebwasser, Town & Village of Red Hook
Frank T. Weber, Jr., Town of Stanford
Carl S. Wolfson, Town of Wappinger
Gayle Zelazny, Town of Pawling
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
37 07/07/2015
IV. Cases and Trials of Note
Phoenix Constr. Co v. The Steamer Poughkeepsie, 212 US 558 (1908) affg 162 F. 494 (1908)
A construction company brought an action against a steamer for damages caused to certain borings in
connection with test holes being made in a river for the purpose of locating an aqueduct. The court
dismissed the case for want of admiralty jurisdiction, concluding that the damaged items were
structures connected with the shore and immediately concerned commerce upon land. The structures
were not aids to navigation in the maritime sense, but extensions of the shore and aids to commerce
on land as such. The project was not suggestive of maritime affairs. It was supplying water to a city,
and the mere fact of the means being carried under the bed of a river, with extensions through the
river to the surface, did not create any maritime right. The court's admiralty jurisdiction had not been
extended by the United States Supreme Court as argued by the company, and the court rejected its
theory that admiralty court jurisdiction could be extended to any claim for damages by any ship. The
United States Supreme Court affirmed the dismissal, without opinion, citing Cleveland Terminal &
Valley Railroad Company v. Cleveland Steamship Company, 208 U.S. 316; The Troy, 208 U.S. 321.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crown v. William Prendergast
1
BACKGROUND
The manorial system of land tenure, first introduced to New York by the Dutch, was continued under
English rule. Patents to huge tracts of land were granted to a few powerful colonists who in turn
granted leases that provided for a perpetual rent to the farmers who worked the land. Failure to pay
the rent resulted in ejection from the property. Also, without freehold title, many farmers could not
meet the property qualifications to vote in elections and serve on juries. Although Dutchess County
was subject to the Philipse patent, the farmers leased their lands from the Wappinger Indians. In 1765,
the Philipse family went to court and successfully enforced their claim against the Wappingers.
Immediately, their representatives imposed manorial leases on tenant farmers. This was met with
strong resistance. The farmers rallied behind Wappinger Sachem Daniel Nimhan, who appealed the
case to the Court of Chancery. No attorney could be found to represent the Sachem, and the court was
comprised of men who owned large landed estates. When the Court of Chancery rejected the appeal,
the Philipse estate brought fifteen actions to eject tenant farmers from their holdings. In November
1765, the local farmers met and agreed to reinstate the dispossessed tenants by force, if necessary. A
governmental proclamation issued on April 30, 1766, offered a reward for the seizure of specifically
named leaders of the farmers’ movement, including William Prendergast. By the end of June, 1766, the
movement involved approximately 1,700 tenant farmers, armed with firearms. They were known as
"levelers," because they believed that their equitable claim to the land should be recognized and their
leases converted into fee simple titles. On June 20th, the Governor's Council sent the Twenty-eight
Regiment to disperse the crowd and arrest the leaders. William Prendergast was detained on a charge
of treason and taken to a New York prison.
1
The following is taken verbatim (with thanks to Frances Murray) from the Historical Society of the New York Courts’
website.
38 07/07/2015
THE TRIAL
In July, the Court of Assizes sat in Dutchess County under military guard. The bench was comprised
of Chief Judge Daniel Horsmanden, and associate justices Johns Watts, William Walton, Oliver De
Lancey, Joseph Reade, William Smith, Whitehead Hicks, and John Morin Scott. All were among the
landed gentry of the colony and Justice Robert R. Livingston was present in court although not sitting.
On Wednesday, August 6, 1766, William Prendergast, a "sober, honest, and industrious Farmer much
beloved by his neighbors," was indicted on a charge of High Treason. The jury trial lasted twenty-four
hours and was widely followed. Prendergast, assisted by his wife, Mehitabel Wing, conducted his own
defense. It is reported that "she never failed to make every remark that might tend to extenuate the
offence, and put his conduct in the most favorable point of View; not suffering one Circumstance that
could be collected from the Evidence, or thought of in his Favour to escape the Notice of the Court and
Jury." The prosecuting attorney sought (but failed) to remove her "lest she might too much influence
the Jury" by "her very Looks." The jury returned a verdict of "guilty" with a recommendation of mercy,
but the court sentenced Prendergast to be hung, drawn and quartered.
AFTERMATH
Mehitabel Wing immediately appealed to Governor Harry Moore who, on September 1, 1766, granted
a reprieve until the King's pleasure might be known. Prendergast later received a royal pardon and was
able to return to his farm. Decades later, the anti-rent movement would again become a force in New
York politics.
SOURCES
Mark, I. and Handlin, O. “Land Cases in Colonial New York (1765-1767): The King v. William
Prendergast” 19 NYU. L. Q. Rev. 165 (1941-1942).
Mark, I. “Agrarian Revolt in Colonial New York, 1766” 1 American Journal of Economics and Sociology
111 (1942).
Benjamin, V. The History of the Hudson River Valley. (New York: Overlook press, 2014), 129 et seq.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Steven A. Pagones v. Alton H. Maddox, Jr., C. Vernon Mason, Al Sharpton, and Tawana Brawley
At the conclusion of the defamation trial in the Tawana Brawley case in July, 1998, the jury awarded
Steven A. Pagones $345,000 in damages against Rev. Al Sharpton, C. Vernon Mason, Alton H. Maddox,
Jr., and Ms. Brawley.
The jury found that they defamed Pagones, a former prosecutor, by falsely accusing him of abducting
and raping Brawley, a black teenager.
Pagones also sued Ms. Brawley, who never appeared at the trial; her damages were later set by the
judge, Barrett Hickman.
In 1988, a grand jury ruled that Ms. Brawley's story was a hoax and specifically exonerated Mr.
Pagones. The New York Times reported on October 7, 1998: “Concluding a seven-month investigation,
a New York State grand jury reported an avalanche of evidence yesterday that Tawana Brawley had
39 07/07/2015
fabricated her tale of abduction and sexual assault in the hands of a gang of racist white men last
year.”
2
The panel, in a 170-page report, released minutely detailed medical, scientific and eyewitness evidence
that the black teenager had concocted the degrading condition in which she was found in Wappingers
Falls, NY, on Nov. 28 by smearing herself with feces, writing racial slurs on her body, and faking a
traumatized daze.
In October of 1998, awarding damages against the non-appearing Brawley, Judge Hickman wrote:
A countervailing consideration is the sense that on a continuing basis, Brawley may well
have been subject to manipulation by her parents and her advisors who have used her
for their own purposes. Tawana Brawley appears caught up in her own fiction and
unwilling or unable to recognize the grief and hurt she caused those she wrongly
accused, especially the Crist family, who the Court hopes has found solace in the verdict
of the jury after all their suffering.
In establishing the amount of damages, the Court believes it would be inappropriate for
the reasons noted to award a huge sum. On the other hand, Brawley is the one person
most responsible for the false charges; therefore, the Court believes she should be held
at least as accountable as Mr. Mason, the defendant held most responsible by the jury.
Accordingly, the Court makes a punitive award in the amount of One Hundred Eighty
Thousand Dollars ($180,000.00) against Brawley in favor of Pagones.
At the end of the trial this Court stated "Let us hope after 10½ years, the Tawana
Brawley matter is finally laid to rest and we can move forward at last to promote healing
and racial harmony."
Unfortunately, the continuing rhetoric by Brawley and her supporters refusing to accept
the verdict does nothing to further racial harmony. In fact, in this particular case it is a
disservice to the African American community since it diminishes credibility and may
adversely affect other viable complaints. This Court recognizes that it is perfectly proper
in appropriate circumstances to speak out against any legitimate racial injustice. In this
case, the injustice was against those wrongfully accused of heinous crimes that never
occurred. The jury did justice by righting that wrong. Brawley and her supporters have
no right to claim that justice was not accomplished by this jury.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2
McFadden, R. “Brawley Made up Story of Assault, Grand Jury Finds,” N.Y. Times, Oct. 7, 1988.
40 07/07/2015
V. County Resources
a. Bibliography
Bailey, H., Meyers, H. and Spaight, J. Local Tales and Historical Sketches (early history of Poughkeepsie
and Fishkill). (Rhinebeck, NY: Kinship, c1994).
Blumer, R., Hovde, E. and Meyer, M. An Empire of Reason by Middlemarch films. (First Run/Icarus
Films; New York Bar Foundation).
Celebrating the Poughkeepsie Tricentennial, 1687 to 1987: 300 Years of People, Pride & Progress
(Poughkeepsie, NY: Trish Adams Associates & Hamilton Reproductions with Chet Karpinski, 1987).
Chester, A. “Dutchess County” in Legal and Judicial History of New York. (1911): 86-91.
Commemorative Biographical Record of the Counties of Dutchess and Putnam Counties. (J.H. Beers &
Co., 1897).
Clark, J. Dutchess County, 1778: "Year of Trial, Year of Transition" (1941-1983).
Corning, A., Emsley, J. and Jewell, W. Southeastern New York, A History of the counties of Ulster,
Dutchess, Orange, Rockland, and Putnam, Vols. 1-3. (New York: Lewis Historical Publishing, 1946).
Dutchess County Board of Supervisors. Old Miscellaneous Records of Dutchess County, The Second
Book of the Supervisors and Assessors. (Poughkeepsie, NY: Vassar Brothers Institute, 1909).
Dutchess County Genealogical Society. Index to History of Dutchess County, New York: with illustrations
and biographical sketches of some. (Interlaken, NY: Heart of the Lakes Pub., 1980).
Dutchess County Historical Society Yearbook, 1914 – present.
Dutchess County, NY - Its People, History and Culture Book Collection on CD. The Dutchess County, New
York Histories book collection is a group of 16 books that detail the history of Dutchess County -
primarily in the 19th and early 20th centuries. Includes:
-Ackert, A. “Dutchess County in Colonial Days.” (1898)
-Ackert, A. “Dutchess County.” (1899)
-Federal Writers’ Project. “Dutchess County.” (1937)
-NY Board of Supervisors. “Old Miscellaneous Records of Dutchess County.” (1909)
-Hasbrouck, F. and Matthieu, S. “History of Dutchess County, New York.” (1909)
-Barber, G. “Index of Wills of Dutchess County, New York, 1742-1832.”
-Smith, P. “General History of Dutchess County, New York, from 1609 to 1876, inclusive (1877).”
-ICON Group International, Inc. “Dutchess County – Webster’s Timeline History Book
Description.” (2009)
Dutchess County. The National Register of Historic Places in Dutchess County, New York (Poughkeepsie,
NY, 1979).
Fish, H. Early History of Dutchess County by Hamilton Fish. (1976).
Ghee, J. and Spence, J. A Century of Change, Poughkeepsie 1898-1998. (Charleston, SC: Arcadia, 2000).
Ghee, J. and Spence, J. Half way up the Hudson (Images of America, 1997).
From English Colony to Sovereign State: Essays on the American Revolution in Dutchess County.
(Poughkeepsie, NY: Dutchess County American Revolution Bicentennial Commission, 1983).
41 07/07/2015
Hasbrouck, F. History of Dutchess County New York. (Poughkeepsie, NY, 1909). (Particularly, p. 498 et
seq of the history of the Dutchess County Bench and Bar.)
Hill, T. Dutchess County (2011).
Jeanneney, J. and Jeanneney, M. Dutchess County, a Pictorial History. (Donning Publishing, 1983).
Kelly, A. Scrapbook of Dutchess County, NY People and Places: 1930-1960 with index.
Lynd, S. Anti-Federalism in Dutchess County. (Chicago: Loyola University Press, 1962).
MacCracken, H. Blithe Dutchess. (New York: Hastings House, 1958).
MacCracken, H. Old Dutchess Forever (Hastings House: New York, 1956).
New York State Council on the Arts. Landmarks of Dutchess County (1683-1867). (New York, 1969).
Platt, E. Eagle’s History of Poughkeepsie” 1683-1905. (1865).
Poughkeepsie: Queen City of the Hudson. [videorecording] (Main Street Productions, c1992).
Pugsley, V. Portraits of Dutchess: 1680-1807. (Poughkeepsie, NY: Hamilton Reproductions, 1976).
Reflections on a River - The Hudson River in Dutchess County History. Wahlberg, H., ed. (Dutchess
County Historical Society Year Book, Volume 88, 2009).
Reynolds, H. Poughkeepsie: The Origin and Meaning of the Word. (Poughkeepsie, NY: 1924).
Rhinevault, C. and Rhinevault, T. Hidden History of the Mid-Hudson Valley Stories from the Albany Post
Road. (Charleston, SC: The History Press, 2011).
The Role of Dutchess County During the American Revolution. Fredriksen, B., ed. (c1976).
Slavery, Antislavery and the Underground Railroad: a Dutchess County Guide / researched by members
(Poughkeepsie, NY: Hudson House, c2010).
Smith, J. History of Duchess County, New York 1683-1882 (Syracuse, 1882).
Smith, P. General History of Duchess County from 1609 to 1876 Inclusive. (1877).
Transformations of an American County Dutchess County, New York 1683-1983. Ghee, J., ed. (Dutchess
County Historical Society, 1986).
Two Hundred and Fifty Years: Commemorating the Two Hundred and Fiftieth Anniversary of the
Founding of the City of Poughkeepsie. (New York, 1937).
Wahlberg, H. In Their Own Words, Telling Dutchess County (Dutchess County Historical Society).
Vassar Brothers Inst. Book of the Supervisors of Dutchess County, NY, 1718-1722 (Poughkeepsie, NY).
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
42 07/07/2015
b. County legal records and their location
Court records are maintained under the aegis of the Dutchess County Clerk, Brad Kendall (above)
Earliest court records date from 1721. There are some 118 boxes of records covering the period 1721-
1894, commencing with the Dutchess County Court of Common Pleas, replaced by County Court under
the Constitution of 1846) (See “The Organization of a Court of Common Pleas in Dutchess County,”
Dutchess County Historical Society Yearbook, Vol. 12. (1927), 30-32.)
The records of the Dutchess County Court of Common Pleas are stored at the County Records Center at
170 Washington St. in Poughkeepsie Access is through the County Clerk by appointment. These early
records consist largely of judgments, debt actions, bail certificates, arrest warrants, and the like.
Because Dutchess County was administered by Ulster County until 1713 Dutchess County has no court
records dating before 1713, and there are no known records in Dutchess County covering the period
1713 to 1721. Researchers should consult early Ulster County records for possible documentation of
Dutchess County matters during the period that Dutchess County was administered by Ulster County.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
43 07/07/2015
c. County history contacts
County, City, Town and Village Historians
COUNTY HISTORIAN
Dutchess County Historian: William P. Tatum III
(845) 486-2381 / Fax: (845) 486-2138
22 Market Street, Poughkeepsie, New York 12601
Dutchess County Historical Society
(845) 471-1630
Post Office Box 88, Poughkeepsie, New York 12602
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CITY HISTORIANS
Beacon Historical Society
Robert Murphy
(845) 831-0514
Post Office Box 89, Beacon, New York 12508
Poughkeepsie Historian
George Lukacs
(845) 471-5066
62 Civic Center Plaza, Poughkeepsie, New York 12601
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOWN AND VILLAGE HISTORIANS
Amenia Historian
Arlene Iuliano
(845) 373-9088
Amenia Town Hall, 4988 Route 22, Amenia, New York 12501
Amenia Historical Society
Norman Moore
(845) 373-9338
Post Office Box 22, Amenia, New York 12501
44 07/07/2015
Beekman Historian
Thom Usher
(845) 724-5364 / (845) 475-5617
96 Hillside Road, Poughquag, New York 12570
Clinton Historian
Craig Marshall
(845) 242-5879
820 Fiddlers Bridge Road, Rhinebeck, New York 12572
Clinton Historical Society
Mary Jo Nickerson
(845) 266-3066
Post Office Box 122, Clinton Corners, New York 12514
Dover Historian
Valerie Larobardier
(845) 849-6025
Post Office Box 478, Dover Plains, New York 12522
Dover Historian
Caroline Reichenberg
Post Office Box 478, Dover Plains, New York 12522
East Fishkill Historian
David Koehler
(845) 226-8877
Post Office Box 245, Hopewell Junction, New York 12533
East Fishkill Historical Society
Malcolm Mills
(845) 227-5374
Post Office Box 245, Hopewell Junction, New York 12533
Fishkill (Town) Historian
Willa Skinner
45 07/07/2015
(845) 896-9888
Post Office Box 133, Fishkill, New York 12524
Fishkill (Town) Historical Society
Steve Lynch
(914) 525-7667
Post Office Box 133, Fishkill, New York 12524
FISHKILL (Village) Historian
Karen Hitt
(845) 896-8022
40 Broad Street, Fishkill, New York 12524
Hyde Park Historian
Vacant
Hyde Park Historical Society
Patsy Costello
(845) 229-2559
Post Office Box 182, Hyde Park, New York 12538
LaGrange Historian
Georgia Herring-Trott
(845) 452-2911
Post Office Box 112, LaGrangeville, New York 12540
LaGrange Historical Society
Bob D’Amato
(845) 489-5183
Post Office Box 112, LaGrangeville, New York 12540
Milan Historian
June Gosnell
(845) 876-8363
Milan Town Hall, 20 Wilcox Circle, Milan, New York 12571
Milan Historian
Patrick Higgins
46 07/07/2015
(845) 834-2599
Milan Town Hall, 20 Wilcox Circle, Milan, New York 12571
Millbrook Historian
David Greenwood
(845) 677-5767
3248 Sharon Turnpike, Millbrook, New York 12545
Millbrook Historical Society
Laurie Duncan
(845) 677-0323
Post Office Box 135, Millbrook, New York 12545
Millerton / North East Historian
Mike Williams
(518) 398-6531
7604 Route 82, Pine Plains, New York 12567
Millerton / North East Historical Society
Ed Downey
(518) 789-4442
Post Office Box 727, Millerton, New York 12546
Pawling (Town) Historian
Robert Reilly
(845) 855-5040
160 Charles Colman Blvd, Pawling, New York 12564
Pawling (Village) Historian
Drew Nicholson
(845) 855-3387
18 Valley Drive, Pawling, New York 12564
Historical Society of Quaker Hill and Pawling
John Brockway
(845) 855-5395
Post Office Box 99, Pawling, New York
47 07/07/2015
Pine Plains Historian & Pine Plains Historical Society
Ann Simmons
(518) 398-5344
Post Office Box 243, Pine Plains, New York 12567
Pleasant Valley Historian
Fred Schaeffer
(845) 454-1190
1544 Main Street (Route 44) Pleasant Valley, New York 12569
Pleasant Valley Historical Society
Marilyn Bradford
(845) 518-0998
Poughkeepsie (Town) Historian
John R. Pinna
Town Office: (845) 485-3646
1 Overrocker Road, Poughkeepsie, New York 12603
Red Hook Historian
J. Winthrop Aldrich
(917) 825-9175
Post Office Box 338, Red Hook, New York 12571
Egbert Benson Historical Society of Red Hook
Claudine Klose
(845) 758-1920
Post Office Box 397, Red Hook, New York 12571
Rhinebeck (Town and Village) Historian
(Town) Nancy Kelly
(845) 876-4592
(Village)
Michael Frazier
(845) 876-7462
Rhinebeck Historical Society
David Miller
48 07/07/2015
(845) 750-4486
Post Office Box 291, Rhinebeck, New York 12572
Stanford Historian
Dorothy Burdick
(845) 868-1366
Stanford Historical Society
Kathy Spiers
(845) 868-7320
Post Office Box 552, Bangall, New York 12506
Tivoli Historian
Bernie Tieger
(845) 757-5481
Post Office Box 311, Tivoli, New York 12583
Union Vale Historian
Fran Wallin
(845) 724-5600
249 Duncan Road, LaGrangeville, New York 12540
Union Vale Historical Society
Henry Kading
(845) 677-8174
303 Verbank Road, Millbrook, New York 12545
Wappinger (Town) and Wappinger’s Falls (Village) Historian
Brenda Von Berg No E-Mail
(845) 297-4158
Wappinger Co-Town Historian
Joey Cavacinni
(845) 298-1150
20 Middle Bush Road, Wappingers Falls, NY 12590
Wappinger’s Falls Co-Village Historian
Mary Schmaltz
(845) 297-4158
Wappingers Historical Society
Sandra Vacchio
(845) 430-9520
49 07/07/2015
Post Office Box 174, Wappinger Falls, New York 12590
Washington Historian
David Greenwood
(845) 677-5767
3248 Sharon Turnpike, Millbrook, New York 12545
Washington Historical Society
Laurie Duncan
(845) 677-0323
Post Office Box 135, Millbrook, New York 12545
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Location of Records
Vassar College Library
(845) 437-7000
124 Raymond Ave, Poughkeepsie, NY 12604
Marist College Library
John Ansley, Archivist
(845) 575-3000
North Road, Poughkeepsie NY
Adriance Memorial Library
Lynn Lucas, Local History Librarian
(845) 485-3445 x3311
Market Street, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601
Dutchess County Records Office
(845) 486-2120
22 Market Street, Poughkeepsie NY 12601
Brad Kendall, County Clerk
(845) 431-1770
Dutchess County Surrogate's Court
10 Market Street, Poughkeepsie NY 12601
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
County Clerk’s Office
The Dutchess County Clerk, Brad Kendall, is custodian of all county filings. The chronologies are far too
long to list, but the subjects on file are available from the County Clerk’s office.
