BIOLOGY HONORS
SCIENCE CURRICULUM 224 GRADES 9 - 12
Investigations for Chapter 16
Origin of New Species
Investigation 16A – Natural Selection
Charles Darwin collected many facts to support
the theory of evolution by natural selection. Yet,
he never examined some remarkable examples of
natural selection that were going on around him in
the English countryside, such as the selection
process involving the peppered moth, Biston
betularia (BIS ton bet choo LAR ee a).
The Industrial Revolution began in the middle of
the eighteenth century. Since that time, tons of
soot had been deposited around the industrial
areas of England. -Soot, the ash created from
burning coal and wood, discolored and generally
darkened the surfaces of trees, rocks, and other
features of the landscape. It also destroyed the -
lichens that once grew in these areas. Lichens are
associations of algae and fungi that frequently
encrust the bark of trees. Many lichens are light in
color. Before the Industrial Revolution, the
peppered -moths that lived among the trees also
were light colored.
In 1848, the first dark-colored peppered moth was
observed and recorded. A century later, 90 percent
or more of the peppered moths in some areas were
dark in color. More than 70 species of moths in
England changed from light to dark coloration.
Similar observations have been made in other
industrial nations, including the United States.
How did this striking change in coloration come
about? Was the change related to the way in
which one species is thought to evolve normally
from another? Or was it a unique occurrence?
In this investigation, you will answer these
questions by interpreting the results of some
experiments. It will be helpful to keep the
following information in mind:
1. Hereditary characteristics of parent organisms
are passed on to their offspring.
2. Changes can occur in the hereditary material of
the parents to produce offspring with
characteristics different from those of the
parents. These changes are known as
mutations.
3. If the different form, called a mutant, survives
and reproduces, it may pass on the new trait, or
mutation, to future generations.
Materials (per team of 3)
paper and pencil
Procedure
1. Read the following description of an
experiment with chemicals from soot: The
peppered moth has a one-year life cycle. The
egg hatches into a larva (caterpillar), which
feeds on tree leaves. The animal then goes
through a dormant stage and is finally
transformed into an adult moth. In 1926, a
British scientist fed leaves treated with certain
chemicals found in soot to the larvae of light-
colored moths. The larvae then were permitted
to go through the normal life cycle. Eventually,
the larvae changed into light-colored adult
moths. These moths were allowed to mate and
produce offspring. When the scientist counted
these offspring, 8 percent of the new moths
were found to be dark-colored. Because this
rate of mutation was much higher than normal,
the scientist claimed that the chemicals found
in soot caused changes to the hereditary
material that determines body color in the
peppered moth. When the experiment was
repeated by other scientists, however, their
results showed much less than 8 percent dark-
colored offspring. Moreover, it was found that
light-colored moth larvae that were fed on
unpolluted leaves produced about as many
dark-colored moths as those fed on polluted
leaves.
2. Answer Analysis questions 1 through 3.
3. Read the following description of an
experiment in an unpolluted forest: More
recently another experiment was performed
with Riston betularia. A large number of both
the light and dark forms of the moths were
captured. The underside of each moth was
marked with a small spot of paint for
identification. Known numbers of these
marked moths were then released in an
unpolluted forest. After a period of time, moths
were collected from this forest and the marked